| Platinum | Doris Italian Market & Bakery |
| Gold | Antonio's Pizza & Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Disalvo's Pizza & Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Broccolini Cafe |
| Top Pick | Broadwalk Restaurant & Grille |
| Top Pick | Carmela's |
| Top Pick | Mundi's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pizzarella |
| Top Pick | Sardelli Steakhouse |
| Top Pick | Sonny's Famous Steak Hogies |