| Platinum | Florio's Restaurant of Hollywood |
| Gold | Capone's Flicker Lite |
| Silver | Antonio's Pizza & Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Conca D'Oro |
| Top Pick | Capone's Italian Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Disalvo's Pizza & Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Mauros |
| Top Pick | Pizza Rustica |
| Top Pick | Vannucchi Brothers Pizza |